Keeping oil temperatures within limits is an incremental endeavor that is won and lost in small performance improvements that add up in small 5-10 degree leaps. You’ll need to construct a robust system that includes enough of these improvements to keep your engine cool, but you won’t know how much effort to exert until you’ve started flying collected measurements. Some builders bolt on whatever they can find and fly happily into the sunset. Others have to work hard to get every degree that they can.
The whole oil cooler situation can be frustrating. It is clearly a part of the engine system, but if you ask an engine manufacturer what kind of oil cooler to use, they’ll tell you to consult the airframe manufacturer, since it’s not an engine part, but an airframe part. You can ask the folks who sell the oil cooler how much support is required, and they’ll tell you “as much as you can provide.” This is obviously of little help to the homebuilder.
One good strategy is to find someone else’s successful installation and duplicate it. There have been many successful oil cooler installations, and many unsuccessful installations. If you can keep the temperatures where you’d like without any structural cracks in 50 or so hours of flying, then you’ll know you’ve done it right. It is not advisable to duplicate an installation that has not yet proven itself in service. Consider type-certificated airplanes of a similar performance envelope, and if all else fails, see how the RV guys do it. Be aware though that several Bearhawk builders have found the basic configuration drawn by Vans to be inadequate, perhaps due to our lower cruise speeds and generally larger engines. Then again, several RV builders have come to the same conclusions.
First, which oil cooler should you choose? There are two major construction categories, drawn cup (below, left) and bar and plate (below, right).

Aeroclassics sells the latter as a high efficiency version. The ends of the cooler will reveal the type.
Drawn Cup:

Bar and Plate:

Both types of cooler construction are be stacked into layers to determine the cooler size. For engines less than 180hp, smaller 7 and 9 row coolers may be adequate. Larger engines will probably require larger coolers, perhaps 13 rows or more.
High efficiency coolers are also available as single pass or dual pass. The dual pass coolers have two stages, so you can think of them as two small coolers in series.
We recommend new or professionally reconditioned oil coolers, because they are a common trap for engine debris. While you are ordering, get the appropriate steel AN fittings for the size of the lines you’ll be using. Most Lycomings use 5/8” (AN-8) lines, and most coolers are provided with pipe threads. Fittings to consider include AN816 (straight), AN823 (45 degrees), and AN822 (90 degrees). The lines will need to be flexible, and should be fire sleeved and pressure tested before you use them. 500 PSI is plenty. Some builders have found that smaller -6 lines restrict flow, thus slowing the oil enough to allow it to spend slightly more time in the cooler, and thus lower temperatures.
The mounting location will vary depending on the type of oil cooler you choose, and where it will fit. One option is in front of the engine, with the oil flow horizontal and the airflow vertical. For Lycomings, this would be in front of the number 2 cylinder, since it is positioned further aft than the number 1 cylinder. In this location, the cooler will have access to intake air that has not been warmed by the engine. This location will require longer hoses though, since the engine oil outlet and inlet are at the accessory case. Another option is vertical on the aft baffle (air flow horizontal), usually behind the number 4 cylinder. Both of these baffle-mounted locations will require structural enhancements to the baffles, which will need to carry the heavy cooler without generating cracks in the long term. The cooler will be subject to all engine vibrations, which will be substantial.
Mounting the cooler off of the engine will reduce its exposure to vibration, but will require flexible ducting to get the air from the high pressure area above the engine to the cooler. 4” SCAT type ducts are often used, but keep in mind that the rough surface inside the duct can generate pressure-robbing turbulence. Consider also SCEET type of duct, which has a smoother interior. You’ll get the best performance if you can make bends with smooth fiberglass plenums, while using the flexible duct on the straight runs. Plenums are available from Airflow Systems, or you can make them using lost foam male mold techniques (Google it).
When bolting the cooler in place, put tubing spacers that run between the two flanges of the cooler so the mounting bolts engage both flanges and don’t compress them together. The flanges of the cooler are aluminum, and as substantial as they seem, a single flange isn’t intended to support the cooler by itself. They are very soft and bend easily.

If your installation proves successful, please come back and add a comment with the details, or provide some documentation for the Beartracks newsletter, or a post on the message board. Successful data points are welcome.
Photos of a successful installation provided by Mark Goldberg:





